When RKO’s
1938 screwball comedy-mystery
The Mad Miss Manton (TMMM)
was shown on TCM, our genial host Robert Osborne noted that Barbara Stanwyck and
Henry Fonda had made three films together, all comedies:
TMMM,
The Lady Eve, and
You Belong to Me, the latter two released in 1941.
Set in then-contemporary New York City (but actually filmed in Burbank, CA in
100-degree heat, according to John M. Miller’s
TCM article!),
TMMM came first. Director Leigh Jason had
also worked with Stanwyck and co-star Hattie McDaniel in
The Bride Walks Out
(1936), before McDaniel won her Best Supporting Actress Oscar for
Gone
With The Wind (1939).
Stanwyck’s
part was originally meant for Katharine Hepburn, but
Bringing Up Baby’s
bad box office put the kibosh on that, though of course nowadays it’s hailed as
a classic. Besides, things worked out fine for Hepburn, as she moved on to her
Oscar-nominated performance in
The Philadelphia Story (1940), among so
many other triumphs. In any case, Stanwyck’s flair for comedy is just right for
her role as Melsa Manton, madcap heiress extraordinaire. That’s my favorite kind
of heiress, especially if she’d like to plunk a few bucks into my pocket during
one of her charity scavenger hunts!
Melsa Manton has
The Thin Man’s Nick and Nora Charles beat when it comes
to chic yet zany sleuthing, at least when it comes to sheer numbers: she has
eight gorgeous debutante girlfriends who are as loyal as they are endearingly
kooky, with no-nonsense maid Hilda (McDaniel) shaking her head at these nutty
rich folks. For the most part, the girls are happy to help Melsa solve murders,
the occasional growled threat or thrown knife notwithstanding.
Fun Fact:
Melsa and her eight gal pals were no doubt playfully modeled on the northeastern
women’s colleges known as “The Seven Sisters:”
Barnard;
Bryn Mawr;
Mount Holyoke;
Radcliffe;
Smith;
Vassar; and
Wellesley. Of course, this being a Hollywood movie, another “sister” was
added. That’s Hollywood for you, always making everything bigger and bolder!
We first meet Melsa walking a gaggle of cute little dogs at the ungodly hour of
3 a.m.; is this how our pet-loving heroine makes extra spending money, or does
she prefer to take her pets walkies when the neighbors are in bed, unaware
Melsa’s pooches are leaving, er, souvenirs? She notices Rex Realty signs
plastered all over the house. Turns out it belongs to Sheila Lane (Leona Maricle,
who’d also worked with Stanwyck in
My Reputation), the wife of
wealthy banker George Lane. Suddenly a car speeds past the site of the new
subway. Melsa recognizes local gent Ronnie Belden (William Corson). Unlike the
usual stereotype of New Yorkers who mind their own business, Melsa lets her
curiosity get the best of her. Her impromptu investigation brings her to the
deserted Lane house, where she finds a diamond brooch—and Lane’s bloodied body!
As she flees in panic, Melsa drops the brooch. By the time Melsa gets ahold of
Lieutenant Mike Brent (Team Bartilucci fave Sam Levene from
The Killers;
After The Thin Man; Shadow of The Thin Man; Last Embrace), the corpse has
gone AWOL.
 |
Don’t worry about the press as long as
they
spell your name right! |
Lt. Brent and the rest of New York’s Finest are pretty darn peeved,
considering that Melsa and her friends have a reputation as merry pranksters.
Too bad our heroine happens to be dressed in a Little Bo-Peep costume for an
artists’ ball, which doesn’t exactly do wonders for her credibility. Granted,
Melsa swears their playful pranks were only meant to draw positive attention for
the good causes they work on in the name of their various charities, like
running a TB clinic and other helpful, clean-cut activities. Melsa and her pals
clearly mean well, but haven’t they ever heard that charity begins at home?
Maybe they should stay out of trouble by making lanyards for the poor or
something. To add insult to injury, not only do Lt. Brent and his men refuse to
investigate, but Peter Ames (Fonda), editor of
The Morning Clarion,
writes a stern article about Melsa’s hijinks, resulting in much comical
slapping. One lawsuit, coming right up! With their
reputations on the line, Melsa and the girls become amateur sleuths.
Debutante
Roll Call, sound off now!
Frances Mercer as Helen Frayne, the most sensible of Melsa’s gorgeous friends. The daughter of prominent East Coast sportswriter Sid Mercer, the raven-haired beauty was a “Powers Girl” model in New York in her teens back in the 1930s (as were my dear mom and aunt. Wish I could’ve been a fly on the wall with those gals swapping stories). Mercer went on to act and sing on stage, screen, and TV, including the Broadway musicals All the Things you Are; Very Warm for May; and Something for the Boys. - Kay Sutton as Gloria Hamilton. This lovely brunette’s screen credits include Carefree; The Saint in New York; Vivacious Lady. Gloria gets a nice punch line when the girls find what may or may not be bodily fluids:
Dora: “How can that be blood? It’s blue.”
Gloria: “Maybe he shot Mrs. Astor.”
|
| Oh, Kay!
|
|
- Catherine O’Quinn as ditzy Dora Fenton. I’m almost certain O’Quinn is one of the blonde Goldwyn Girls in Team Bartilucci fave The Secret Life of Walter Mitty (1947). Anyway, she gets some delightful lines here, especially this TMMM bit, which becomes a running gag:
Melsa: “Helen, you search the upstairs.”
Helen: “Oh, no, I was never much of an individualist. If the upstairs has to be searched, we’ll search it together.”
Dora: “Why, that’s Communism!”
- Whitney Bourne, as Pat James (Blind Alibi; Double Danger; Beauty for the Asking, with Lucille Ball)), who never saw a snack she didn’t like, even at a murder scene! I’m sure Lt. Brent is thrilled to see his crime scene ruined. Hey, Pat, you gonna finish that? Don’t your rich parents feed you at home, you poor little rich girl you?
- Ann Evers as Lee Wilson (If I Were King; Gunga Din; Casanova Brown).
- Linda Perry, billed here as Linda Terry. By any name, she plays Myra Frost, Melsa’s flirty friend. Ms. Perry’s credits include They Won’t Forget; The Great Garrick; and the 1937 movie adaptation of the Perry Mason film The Case of the Stuttering Bishop.
- Vickie Lester (billed as Vicki Lester) as Kit Beverly. Vickie’s star was born in Tom, Dick, and Harry; Tall, Dark, and Handsome; The Great Plane Robbery.
- Eleanor Hanson as Jane. (Guess it's one of those one-word names, like Margo or Annabella.) She also appeared in the Western Flaming Frontiers and bit parts such films as The Story of Vernon and Irene Castle, and worked again with TMMM co-star Penny Singleton in Blondie Goes to College. Wonder if Singleton and Hansen ever reminisced about making TMMM?
 |
| One stiff, hold the mayo! |
Before long,
the lawsuit takes a back seat, along with a corpse or two, as Peter finds
himself falling in love with the spirited Melsa and trying to save her from
shady characters like ex-con Edward Norris (Stanley Ridges of
Possessed; To
Be or Not to Be; Sergeant York), a convicted murderer who’s working on the
subway and just might have a score to settle. Even Blondie gets into the act—no,
not songbird Debbie Harry,
but the original Blondie, Penny Singleton, formerly Dorothy McNulty from After the Thin Man. She’s funny and memorable in
this pre-
Blondie comedy caper as Frances Gluck, who’s stuck on Norris and
tries to convince the girls of his innocence, even trying to pass off the
future Blondie Bumstead as an old chum, with hilarious results and a smattering
of social commentary.
Kit (talking
to Hilda with her mouth full): “Have you another piece of cake, Hilda?”
Hilda: “Yes, I have, but the kitchen’s closed for the night.”
Melsa:
“Hilda! Miss Beverly is our guest.”
Hilda: “I didn’t ask her up!”
Helen:
“Come the revolution, we’ll stop being exploited by our help.”
Melsa
(giving Hilda a wry look):
“In my house, the revolution is here!”
 |
Who needs Charlie's Angels
with 8 crimefighting debs? |
 |
“Lt. Brent, the good news is
we’ve found George Lane’s
body. The bad news…er….”
|
 |
| Blondie Beats a Murder Rap! |
 |
Lt. Brent saves the day!
Who knew he was a counter spy? |
Although
Fonda and Stanwyck were great onscreen, Henry Fonda was less than thrilled with
his role. He’d been borrowed from Walter Wanger Productions and, as Axel Madsin
wrote in his biography
Stanwyck, Fonda “...hated his role, hated the
script's sneering repartee with his leading lady, and tried his best to ignore
everybody.” Fonda himself later admitted, "I was so mad on this picture; I
resented it." Philip G. Epstein’s script from an unpublished Wilson Collison
novel was clearly meant as a female star vehicle, and as Miller suggested,
“Fonda probably did not appreciate the scenes in which he was beaten up by eight
flighty debutantes!” But Fonda got over it, happily co-starring with Stanwyck again in
two other hits, as mentioned earlier, and becoming close friends. In fact, Robert Osborne said Fonda admitted to his subsequent wives that he carried a torch for Stanwyck for the rest of his life (and why not?)!
Here's a link to our pal Dawn Sample's great
Noir and Chick Flicks blog post from 2011!
http://dawnschickflicks.blogspot.com/2011/05/mad-miss-manton-1938_27.html
 |
| I knew those crazy kids would make beautiful music together! |
 |
You say you want a revolution?
Hilda's your go-to gal! |
